Couple told to replace chapel's windows

Shropshire Council has decided Dominic and Sue Hughes will not be allowed to keep the new windows fitted in their former Primitive Methodist Chapel building in Pool Head near Wem.

The couple will now have to replace the windows with ones which meet planning regulations.

The council's north planning committee ruled at a meeting this week the replacement windows had resulted in the loss of major features within the building.

The replacement windows, which are double glazed UPVC with a light oak finish, have been fitted within the existing arched apertures.

The couple had replaced the original windows, which were metal framed and painted white.

In a statement Shropshire Council said: "It is considered that the replacement of the existing windows has resulted in the loss of major features within the overall design and distinctive architectural style of the building, and further that the replacement windows that have been installed are incongruous windows of inappropriate design, proportions and materials.

"The local planning authority considers this has served to significantly detract from the character of the building, harming its significance and diminishing its value as a local heritage asset. The application is unsupported by a heritage assessment to demonstrate or provide justification otherwise."

The scheme was supported by Wem Rural Parish Council, and three letters of support from local residents were sent to Shropshire Council in favour of the windows.

Residents in support said the new windows looked "wonderful" and enhanced the appearance of the property.

Another comment said the old windows were "cheap and nasty" when the chapel was built.

The scheme was originally discussed at a meeting of the planning committee last month when members decided to defer the application.

At the meeting conservation officer Ruth Hitchin told councillors the chapel dated back to 1864.

She added: “The windows are an integral part of the building’s character. The new windows are alien in design. If you start allowing windows to be changed, you may well be in a difficult position.”

But applicant Mr Hughes said: “Soon after we moved in we realised the windows were not fit for purpose.

“It was after the work had been completed, to our horror, we were told planning permission should have been sought.

“We regret not asking for approval but as soon as we realised the mistake we submitted an application duly.”